As the 2025 Major League Baseball (MLB) season approaches, Alex Verdugo finds himself in a precarious position—unsigned and without a single major-league offer. Once hailed as a key component in the high-profile Mookie Betts trade that was part of the Boston Red Sox’s efforts to stay competitive, Verdugo’s trajectory has taken a downturn that leaves many wondering: where did it all go wrong for this once-promising talent?
At the onset of his career, Verdugo showcased immense potential. During the 2020 abbreviated season, he boasted an impressive .308 batting average, which helped lay the groundwork for expectations in subsequent years. His performance in 2021 further reinforced his reputation, but as seasons turned, Verdugo’s production began to wane. By the end of his stint with the Red Sox in 2023, his batting average had dipped to .264, accompanied by a mere 13 home runs and 54 RBIs. While these numbers aren’t terrible in isolation, for a corner outfielder, they lack the allure of a genuine offensive threat.
Hoping to reignite his career, Verdugo was given another chance with the New York Yankees in 2024. Unfortunately, the switch didn’t yield the desired results. Despite appearing in 149 games, he suffered through a lackluster season, finishing with a similar home run count and an even lower batting average of .233. His inconsistency at the plate starkly contrasts with the modern standards of MLB outfielders, where teams increasingly prioritize power hitting, elite defensive skills, or extraordinary on-base abilities. Verdugo’s profile fits into none of these coveted categories, making it challenging for teams to justify investing in him.
Adding complexity to the situation is Verdugo’s reputation within the clubhouse. In 2023, his relationship with Red Sox manager Alex Cora was marred by incidents that included being benched for tardiness. Cora’s public rebuke of Verdugo highlighted concerns regarding his professionalism and commitment to the game. Although not every organization may view such concerns as deal-breakers, reports of poor adherence to team standards and disciplinary issues can lead to significant hesitation among potential suitors.
When the Yankees, known for their investment in proven veterans, opted not to pursue Verdugo after 2024, it underscored the skepticism surrounding his candidacy in free agency. If a storied franchise like New York regarded him as a non-starter, it’s likely other teams have taken note and formed similar conclusions.
Despite being only 28 years old, Verdugo finds himself at a crossroads. While his age suggests there’s still promise for a rebound, his route might depend on circumstances beyond his control, such as injuries within other teams that could open up roster spots. Alternatively, a minor-league deal could serve as a pathway for him to reclaim his once-ascendant status—a chance to prove his worth anew.
Alex Verdugo’s free agency serves as a compelling reminder of the harsh realities of professional sports: talent alone does not guarantee opportunities. In an era where consistency, commitment, and an ability to adapt are prized above all, even a player with remarkable potential can find himself sidelined. Whether Verdugo can adjust, overcome these challenges, and carve out a fruitful MLB career remains a mystery yet to unfold.
